24 Mayhew Dr, South Orange Village Twp., NJ
Welcome home to this classic 1930 stone-front Colonial, blending original character, thoughtful updates, and easy outdoor living. The wide open front porch is a signature feature, offering a gracious place to sit and take in the idyllic upper Wyoming neighborhood setting. Inside, hardwood floors, original built-ins, and a wood-burning fireplace bring warmth & architectural detail. The foyer and living room lead to a sun-drenched family room with a french door to the front porch. The 2023 gut-renovated kitchen is a chef's delight. Open to the dining area, it features quartz counters, tile backsplash, a Thermador appliance package with an induction stove & a double smart oven. The second level finds 3BRs & a full bath w/ a heated floor, plus a third level BR and full bath. The renovated walk-out basement includes a spacious recreation space with laundry, utilities, storage and access to two single car garages. A new side deck is perfect for BBQing, with a stone path to a tucked-away backyard sitting area finished in gravel and framed by greenery. A screened-in back porch adds another quiet retreat, with NYC winter views. Additional improvements include the 2018 roof, 2022 water heater, and 2023 furnace. Just .9 miles to NYC Midtown Direct train, South Orange Village shops, restaurants, and seasonal Farmers Market. South Mountain Reservation hiking trails are close by; Flood's Hill is less than 1 mile away for sledding and year-round events including free summer concerts.
Reviews
As a first-time homebuyer, I couldn’t have asked for a better relator than Amy Paternite. From start to finish, Amy was an incredible resource—walking me through every step of the process with...
Read more
08/25/2025 - jodi berlatt
Amy Paternite was wonderful. She smoothly navigated us through the buying process. She knows Essex County like the back of her hand and her deep knowledge and insights were so helpful at every step.
08/15/2025 - zuser20211113180512759
We worked with Amy Paternite for over six months to find our home, and we truly can’t imagine going through this process with anyone else, especially as first-time home buyers. We relocated from...
Read more
08/14/2025 - zuser20141017102500328
Our experience was amazing with Ben and Amy. I cannot say enough good things about them. They answered all of our questions and returned our phone calls, emails and texts within minutes of us...
Read more
12/05/2024 - jpb1313
Amy and her team were totally amazing from the first conversation. She knows the area very well, and got me the best price when I sold my house. She has an amazing network of partners and contractors...
Read more
04/30/2024 - zuser20171014082429665
Selling a home lived in for 34 years is quite the project! Fortunately, my husband and I had the experience and commitment of the Good Life Group, helmed by Amy Paternite and Ben Garrison, to guide...
Read more
09/26/2023 - ebaxelrod
View more reviews
